Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="alagakkonara" data-source="post: 5347355" data-attributes="member: 128791">You are correct.Agreed.I have made no such argument.Again I have made no such argument. I said the challenge is only for Muslims. Please provide your authentic news. Where can I find this??Again I never said Quran is only for muslims. But as to the question why anyone ever tried to break the challenge, because Muslims themselves say that the challenge is for everyone. Come on, I really expect more than this . You cannot prove anything by giving something someone else did. Maybe they misunderstood the whole thing. Someone trying to break a challenge proves that it is for everyone???? How??? It only states that someone outside Islam tried the challenge. Only conditions laid by the challenger will decide for whom it was intended. Now if you ask me, what really might indicate that the challenge is for everyone is given in the Quran itself.."If the mankind and the     jinns were together to produce the like of this Qur'an, they could not produce     the like thereof, even if they helped one another."     [Qur'an 17:88]Then the interesting question is, if the challenge is for everyone why should it be in Arabic?? And you have not answered this question yet. How did you decide that it should be in Arabic? Remember I have already quoted on the subjectiveness of the word 'like'There are few reasons to say why it is not Universal. But yes, if the language should be arabic, then how can it be universal?Irrelevant. My point is that anyone should be able to accept the challenge in any language he/she prefer, because of the obvious reasons(1) GOD knows all languages(2) There's no part in the challenge where Allah says it should be in arabicThere aren't such languages and irrelevant to the discussion. There's no question on it being in a Universal language, but only on it being in any language. My point is that 'surah like it' can be in any language if the challenge is universal.I have tried my best.Thank you.</blockquote>

Verification: Winadiyakata thappara keeyak tibeda?

Top Bottom