Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="sirajstc" data-source="post: 11951927" data-attributes="member: 91140">"An Assassin"Accusation No.3   "An Assassin"  It  is interesting to note that many of these so called "assassinations"  reported in Ibn Ishaq's or Tabari's works all have something in common,  and that is that because the person who was assassinated insulted the  Holy Prophet (S), were assassinated. However, the scholars have looked  at reports like this and have concluded:   All  such reports, as ascribe the execution of others merely to their having  harrased the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) in the  past, have Ibn Ishaq as the last narrator at the top; and in the  terminology of the traditionalists such reports are called Mursal and  are not to be relied on." (Source:  Sirat-Un-Nabi, by Allama Shibli Nu'Mani, rendered into English by M.  Tayyib Bakhsh Budayuni, Kazi Publications Lahore, Vol. II, p. 199-203,  bold and underlined emphasis ours)   Ali  Sina can however now run and quote from the Authentic Collections of  hadith where it shows that Ka'b bin Al-Ashraf was executed. However, one  must note that there were reports that say Ka'b bin Al-Ashraf planned  to get the Prophet (S) assassinated, and that he went to Makkah to  incite the Pagans to fight the Holy Prophet (S).   Secondly,  Ka'b did all this, despite the fact that the Holy Prophet (S) had a  treaty with the Jews, which clearly says, "Whoever is rebellious or  whosoever seeks to spread enmity and sedition, the hand of every  God-fearing Muslim shall be against him, even if he be his son" (Source:  The Life of Muhammad PBUH by Abdul Hameed Siddiqui, p. 141-142). Thus,  the liar and deceiver Ka'b bin Al-Ashraf had to pay the price, for  planning to assassinate the Holy Prophet (S), and for putting the lives  of the Muslims and the Jews who the Muslims had a treaty with in danger.  </blockquote>

Verification: Payakata winadi keeyak tibeda?

Top Bottom