WHO'S THE BEST UMPIRE AROUND? [VOTE]

[yohantha]

I assume u r refering 2 d desicion he made 2 rule out Sanga on 192 in Australia!
well jst b-cuz he made an error lik tht,doesn't make him a bad umpire n won't stop him been d best either!
Umpires r also human n they r bound 2 make mistakes here n there.Wht v've 2 see 4 ourselves is d one who'll make d least?
Of I ask u 2 name an umpire who hasn't made an error so far,well.... think abtt it!!!!!!
Rudi's desicion hit us hard cuz it was ruled against our own country!
Jst thnk machan,I've no hard feelings,this is wht I feel!!!!!!!!!

What you say is true about humans making errors.And Rudi is also very reluctant to refer decisions to the third umpire.(do u remember the way he gave Sidebottom out during the Eng Vs SL one day series?) to me, he just does not have the correct mindset.

 

[rash87]

What you say is true about humans making errors.And Rudi is also very reluctant to refer decisions to the third umpire.(do u remember the way he gave Sidebottom out during the Eng Vs SL one day series?) to me, he just does not have the correct mindset.

well if u r saying he's jst little reluctant n have a hesitancy over choosing technology,tht cleary doesn't make him a bad umpire!Infact I thnk tht's d ultimate point which makes him d best!It's human who plays dis game n no matter wht d accuracy,desicions shud be made by a human!then only d liveness of d game is preserved!

 

[nuwa1]

for me it's Steve Buknor

 

[blackroses]

voted bucknor

 

[suspect]

Simon Taufel is good

 

[sri_lion]

voted bucknor

Wow! seems Buknor has some impact on Sri Lankans

 

[ishta]

rudi koetzen and darel hair sucks

 

[ishta]

its simon Tuafel for me

 

[nuwanoo7]

Steve Bucknor is the best

 

[supun75]

Aleem Dar thamai