Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="yasas bandara" data-source="post: 20124401" data-attributes="member: 246044">Very disappointed with the Tower of Joy battle. Reasons-1.            From Eddard’s POV, his sister was kidnapped and raped. Now, the most illustrious Knight in the world (a man praised and respected even by his enemies) is standing between him and his sister for no reason and wants to shed blood for no reason (Mad king, his son are dead). This makes zero sense. How can a virtuous person like Ser Dayne sink to this level? Why can’t Eddard ask the most simple question (why are you doing this?) before start fighting? 2.            Robert had already pardoned Ser Barriston and he clearly says he has no intention of punishing those who’re doing their duty. So why didn’t Eddard try to TALK to Ser Dayne and try to stop a pointless bloodshed? Again makes no sense. Eddard clearly didn’t expect ALL his men to survive did he? Ser Dayne was the greatest swordsman.3. In the books, it’s clearly established that Eddard owes his life to Reed. He even explains this to his son. In the series, he lies about it and says he defeated Ser Dayne. This is totally out of character for Eddard (embodiment of virtue). There’s no reason to deny that his life was saved by Lord Reed, his loyal friend who’s loyal enough to send this two children (who never set a foot outside home) to aid Stark’s son.4. Crannogmen fight with unorthodox weapons like frog spears and nets (from the way Meera handles these weapons, they’re very effective). Also Lord Reed is said to have superhuman abilities (it says he can hide his whole tribe from the eyes of others). Him stabbing Ser Dayne on the back is an insult to the character. So basically this one was a lame, half-assed attempt at one of the most important scenes of the story. They’ve spent more effort on useless scenes like Sam vomiting a dozen times.<img src="/styles/default/xenforo/smilies/default/no.gif"  class="smilie" loading="lazy" alt=":no:" title="No    :no:" data-shortname=":no:" /></blockquote>

Verification: Hata thunen beduwama keeyada? (60 bedeema thuna)

Top Bottom