Mistakes in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows

hul2000

Member
Oct 17, 2006
5,050
2
0
39
Gallifrey
Mistake 1

In Chapter 6 - Hermione says she have modified the memories of her parents.

"I've also modified my parents' memories so that they're convinced they're really called Wendell and Monica Wilkins."

But later - In Chapter 9 - She says she never done a memory charm.

"But I've never done a memory charm.'
'Nor have I,' said Hermione"


Mistake 2

Who was the Master of the Elder Wand?

One can be the Master of th Elder Wand only if he/she defeats the previous owner. If you do not defeat the previous owner, but tool the wand, it will be just a wand. It will not give you 'extraordinary magical powers'. The book clearly says this.

As the book says.
Gregorovitch owned the wand and Grindelwald took it from him. Dumbledore defeated Grindelwald and took the wand. Then Draco Malfoy unknowingly defeated Dumbledore (in the 'Lightning Struck Tower'). Harry defeats Draco at 'Malfoy Manor' and so Harry is the Master of the wand.

But the problem is Grindelwald never defeated Gregorovitch. He stole it from him. So he was never the master of the wand. So accordingly Dumbledore, Draco and Harry could not be the Master of the wand.

But Voldemort killed Gregorovitch in his quest for the Elder Wand. so he is the Master of the Elder Wand.


These are the Mistakes I could find. If anyone found some other mistakes or has any explanations for these please comment.
 

wizkido

Banned
Jul 4, 2007
207
0
0
Oh ! for god sake man., They are Mistakes

How can you expect anyone to be interested in mistakes.

Except for X-pert :D:D
 

KishanW

Member
Apr 12, 2007
9,629
24
0
USA
good thing i dnt read the book, just watch the movie:lol:
(but reading the book is really good:yes:, i'm to lazy for that.my bad)
 

dilistic

Member
Apr 4, 2007
2,634
0
0
Singapore
hul2000 said:
Guess not many are interested in mistakes.

:D

lots of ppl havent read it yet actually..

but wow.. u really do have a good eye!

the first one i missed..:(

i noticed the elder wand one tho.. made me a lil confused, but i thought it was probably a mistake on my part.. misinterpretation or smt..


hmm.. i'm gonna read all the 7 together when i am free; back to back..
no time soon tho :(
hehheh..

were u satisfied with the book tho? ;)