-Which movie you watched last? -

Status
Not open for further replies.

twisted

Well-known member
  • Feb 21, 2008
    34,398
    818
    113
    upon purple clouds
    Then even worse. If it's I wouldn't have rated it 7.:baffled:

    that'd be like saying silence of the fucking lambs suck because hannibal lecter didn't have valid enough a reason to go on a killing spree and to eat the kidneys of the victims :oo: ..

    and saying psycho sucked cos the lady in the movie didn't have a motivation to steal all the money she stole..

    I can give you millions of examples, those are just devices to get the plot going.
     

    Tharindu Chat

    Active member
  • Feb 26, 2008
    8,739
    24
    38
    35
    Victoria, British Columbia
    that'd be like saying silence of the fucking lambs suck because hannibal lecter didn't have valid enough a reason to go on a killing spree and to eat the kidneys of the victims :oo: ..

    and saying psycho sucked cos the lady in the movie didn't have a motivation to steal all the money she stole..

    I can give you millions of examples, those are just devices to get the plot going.

    But the thing here is that plot device is not enough strong to hold the movie plus there are big holes in the plot. If plot device's credibility is not that great, it's obvious that the rest of the movie suffers from it, like in Con Air.:)

    And what is to get from the movie? A sociopath traps a man and gets fun by harassing him. Finally when the cops coming, He leaves after killing two men literally for nothing. What the hell is there other than moving frames?:baffled:
     
    Dec 28, 2010
    137
    2
    0
    Sis(assuming you are a sis)
    Why dont you take some time and post your review on the movie .
    Just post the title , image your personal rating and feel free yourself to add whatever the comment on the movie :D


    reviews? well i'm not an expert to comment on directing, editing etc so i'll just try to say how i felt about the movie. :)
     

    twisted

    Well-known member
  • Feb 21, 2008
    34,398
    818
    113
    upon purple clouds
    But the thing here is that plot device is not enough strong to hold the movie plus there are big holes in the plot. If plot device's credibility is not that great, it's obvious that the rest of the movie suffers from it, like in Con Air.:)

    And what is to get from the movie? A sociopath traps a man and gets fun by harassing him. Finally when the cops coming, He leaves after killing two men literally for nothing. What the hell is there other than moving frames?:baffled:

    do you realize that that sorta things do happen in this world? meh, even hell worse happen day by day.. may be you are too young to know that not everything on earth happen for a fair reason. :P phone booth is not one of the best movies I've seen but you are discarding it for the wrong reasons. you are prolly bullshitting on such stuff to come off smart here where you totally go wrong :lol:

    and I think, you should find it very appealing if you stuck to hindi movies where everything happens for a reason and where no plot holes exist :lol:
     

    silentsahan

    Well-known member
  • Apr 28, 2010
    9,737
    1
    3,658
    113
    Rajagiriya
    VCD player එකක් නැති මට ඇයි මෙහෙම කරන්නේ ඔයා සචි....:(
    disappointed.jpg
     

    Zeus

    Well-known member
  • Sep 14, 2007
    20,327
    1,957
    113
    Kalutara
    But the thing here is that plot device is not enough strong to hold the movie plus there are big holes in the plot. If plot device's credibility is not that great, it's obvious that the rest of the movie suffers from it, like in Con Air.:)

    And what is to get from the movie? A sociopath traps a man and gets fun by harassing him. Finally when the cops coming, He leaves after killing two men literally for nothing. What the hell is there other than moving frames?:baffled:

    Dude
    let me have my place :D
     

    Tharindu Chat

    Active member
  • Feb 26, 2008
    8,739
    24
    38
    35
    Victoria, British Columbia
    do you realize that that sorta things do happen in this world? meh, even hell worse happen day by day.. may be you are too young to know that not everything on earth happen for a fair reason. :P phone booth is not one of the best movies I've seen but you are discarding it for the wrong reasons. you are prolly bullshitting on such stuff to come off smart here where you totally go wrong :lol:

    and I think, you should find it very appealing if you stuck to hindi movies where everything happens for a reason and where no plot holes exist :lol:

    It's probably your desire to defend the movie is creating all sorts of unrealistic propositions. There are some holes in the plot which doesn't explain the killer's motive and makes this vulnerable yet you keep saying that unrealistic things happening and so on.:baffled:

    In the first part, given the trapped guy's personality and the attitude-which had been created in the previous scenes-, he wouldn't have stayed on line for more than 30 secs with the caller. and it seems that the NYPD guys have just out of the training as they can't identify a shooting position by the wound. There are many loose points in the plot. No clear motive in killer, loose plot devices - I just discard it for the wrong reasons, Do I?:rolleyes:

    Why the hell do I want to come smart in a online public forum?:lol:
    Besides for your future reference , I'm not into Hindi that much.:)
     

    twisted

    Well-known member
  • Feb 21, 2008
    34,398
    818
    113
    upon purple clouds
    It's probably your desire to defend the movie is creating all sorts of unrealistic propositions. There are some holes in the plot which doesn't explain the killer's motive and makes this vulnerable yet you keep saying that unrealistic things happening and so on.:baffled:


    yeah you already mentioned that about the lack of Motivation, in case you didn't notice I've been replying as to that matter so far.

    there's a clear motivation for the snipers intentions, he keeps saying that to collin farrel I dunno how you missed it, ok prolly cos it wasn't in hindi :lol:

    In the first part, given the trapped guy's personality and the attitude-which had been created in the previous scenes-, he wouldn't have stayed on line for more than 30 secs with the caller. and it seems that the NYPD guys have just out of the training as they can't identify a shooting position by the wound. There are many loose points in the plot. No clear motive in killer, loose plot devices - I just discard it for the wrong reasons, Do I?:rolleyes:

    well the caller was very intriguing wasn't he? and there, another point you've missed, the initial attitude we see on collin farrel is merely pretty false wasn't that part of what sniper was working on? before I go on, have you really seen this movie ? i don't mean as in just kepts your eyes on the screen blankly.

    and your big plot hole is that the police couldn't identify killers direction from the wounds? if that's your biggest plot hole, let me here some of the other holes on the plot please..oh yeah prolly cops didn't have the training that takes to do that..is it so impossible? cops in USA i don't believe as smart as many movies suggest..do you have any valid proofs as to your "cop point"?

    if you've seen shawshank redemption, regarded the best by many fans, you might spot many plot holes that atleast make more sense than that. and so pretty much yeah, I think you are discarding it for no apparent reason.

    Why the hell do I want to come smart in a online public forum?:lol:
    Besides for your future reference , I'm not into Hindi that much.:)

    dunno ..if not, why would you still be there replying on an online forum trying to prove you right? :lol::lol: I mean, if you don't give a damn, why prove you right? just don't lose any sleep over it :P

    but you do have the mentality of many hindi movie fans :P
     
    Status
    Not open for further replies.