1. E

    ශුන්‍යතා දහම

    you cant go like asking this without knowing what you are even asking. first you need to know what buddha referred as rupas, rupaskandas, rupa-upadanaskandas... you cant go mixandmatch, they are not that trivial.
  2. E

    ශුන්‍යතා දහම

    let me ask this way? rupa is an ultimate reality (paramatta succa) is rupaskanda an ultimate reality?
  3. E

    ශුන්‍යතා දහම

    ???
  4. E

    ශුන්‍යතා දහම

    bundle of rupas called rupaskanda? which bundle?
  5. E

    ශුන්‍යතා දහම

    im asking u a simple question. Is the rupa and rupaskanda same? if it is same why rupa is called rupaskanda?
  6. E

    ශුන්‍යතා දහම

    are they referred the same? why used skanda term without using just rupa then?
  7. E

    ශුන්‍යතා දහම

    forget it about upadhanaskandas...first, is he referring rupa or rupaskandas as maro?
  8. E

    ශුන්‍යතා දහම

    in rupam ko maro is he referring rupa or rupa skandha?
  9. E

    ශුන්‍යතා දහම

    you sure about that? where does budda say so?
  10. E

    ශුන්‍යතා දහම

    what do you exclude? aha...can we count on us the same or should we go along traditional less risky way? you tell me, you are the one talking about datu levels of panchaskandas ------ Post added on 1784047727
  11. E

    ශුන්‍යතා දහම

    eye-base = chakku pasada rupa same goes to vedana.. what about those villages then?
  12. E

    ශුන්‍යතා දහම

    eye = eyebase (rupa, not rupa skanda) + external rupa (not rupa skanda) + chakku vinnana... patipada translates to a practical method/path of training. remember this is the 4th requirement to attain sovan ------ Post added on 1784045485
  13. E

    ශුන්‍යතා දහම

    im not saying nothing. you need to understand why rupa (as skandas) not used in those rupa+chakku =chakku vinnana ... once you understood you will see the issue you say about datu level of panchaskanda...
  14. E

    ශුන්‍යතා දහම

    ive heard chakkunca paticca rupam uppajati chakku vinnanam have you ever heard chakkuncha paticca rupa skandam uppajati chakku vinnana skandam ?
  15. E

    ශුන්‍යතා දහම

    not the answer to the question....didnt ask what they are on
  16. E

    ශුන්‍යතා දහම

    what collection of rupas is called rupa skanda?
  17. E

    ශුන්‍යතා දහම

    if rupa = rupa kandha? why is it called kandha? isnt it just rupa?
  18. E

    ශුන්‍යතා දහම

    you mean rupa = rupa skannda?
  19. E

    ශුන්‍යතා දහම

    what is rupa skandha?
  20. E

    ශුන්‍යතා දහම

    what is panchaskanda?

    No contents