Is it wrong if a civilian who supports war gets killed.?

[AtulaSiriwardane]

Another poll, same question..

please. can you remove this poll? it does not have an exact answer that is independent of the situation. why these polls are necessary? if you make a poll then the questions must be crystal clear and they must have exact separate answers.

This is a buddhist country Shiran, and everyone knows what is Karma.. now many westerners also talk about Karma...
This paul clear if you understand that Intention generates Karma.
Anyway, I had already divided the situation and posted another poll..
http://www.elakiri.com/forum/showthread.php?t=145357
I like to see how does the human mind works..(when it works).
Sometimes it is so surprising..

 

[shiran24]

This is a buddhist country Shiran, and everyone knows what is Karma.. now many westerners also talk about Karma...
This paul clear if you understand that Intention generates Karma.
Anyway, I had already divided the situation and posted another poll..
http://www.elakiri.com/forum/showthread.php?t=145357
I like to see how does the human mind works..(when it works).
Sometimes it is so surprising..

not the answer. and you next poll also has the same weekness. a question in a poll must have an exact answer independent of the situation. it is not the case here. your question is not about whether we have to pay for what we do according to karma. it is about justification. it is about whether it is acceptable. bodhisathwa in baka jathaka did kill. i dont know whether he payed or not. but the killing had to be done for the safety of fishes.

 

[sriboysl]

Terrorists Who are with arms and firing to us should kill them all.
Who are supporting terrorist should punished according to law of country .

 

[funkoluwa]

war should b d final choice to gain a solution,

 

[shiran24]

yer. it is so in sri lanka now. isn't it?

 

[rohana1985]

War and Terrorism are two different things!!!!

 

[Wal Bada]

I think the civilians who supports war are not really civilians.
They have the intention to kill as a solution.

Let's see the other side of the coin. Civillians who support the terrorists are not civillians. They have the intention to kill as a solution. So now how does it sound like?

 

[thusi02]

must kill em all.Coz they r true tigers who hides its pith flecks

 

[dh07]

despite their thoughts abt war no civilians lives are supposed to be spilled ... intensions are da base of karma,, but it aint karma til its being executed (Angulimala was stopped b4 his intensions were put 2 action and kill his mother,)...,,

anyone can change but dis doesnt mean all civilians are innocent but their lives matter...so no civilian must die,,
as long as someone is not a threat for another"innocent" life,,no one has da right to judge his life...

war is da way because we cant find another way(other dan gud for nuthin peace talk),,... if v some how find a way,, not even comrades needs to die,,

 

[AtulaSiriwardane]

Let's see the other side of the coin. Civillians who support the terrorists are not civillians. They have the intention to kill as a solution. So now how does it sound like?

You mean "If someone has the intention to kill he is not a civilian"
Perhaps you mean 'He is a barbarian"
Is that so.
And you don't support killing as a solution..

 

[AtulaSiriwardane]

no............. our supporting is essential. we must support war bcos of the reasons that i stated. and yes; if we are supporting war then we are also contributing to kill terrorists. nothing to hide. if the soldiers are doing an akusala karma then we too. and there are situations that we have to do somethings even they are akusala karmas. (however i have a doubt whether this is an akusala karma. what is an akusala karma? can it be defined generally without stating some particular things as akusala karma?) we must act as true humans.

Akuasala Karma is
generating thoughts,
uttering words or
performing actions
based on intention of aversion
toward ANYTHING... ANYONE....

You are 100% correct when you said
"if we are supporting war then we are also contributing to kill terrorists. nothing to hide. if the soldiers are doing an akusala karma then we too. "
You have wisdom.
But even the wise can do wrong because Chanda, because you like doing it.