Is Coulomb law true? Then we can provide enough energy to Sri Lanka with pen torch batteries!

Ridunapm

Well-known member
  • Jun 22, 2022
    2,005
    2,673
    113
    Do you remember coulomb's law? We learned it in middle school. It gives the force between two charges.

    Coulombs-law-is-applicable-to-the-NACAP.png


    So if we place two spheres charged with 1 coulomb negative and positive each, 1 meter apart, the attraction force between them is about 9 Billion Newtons! (9,000,000,000 N!) That is enough force to lift 900,000 tons.

    1 coulomb is not huge. By define of amps, a current flow of 1 ampere for 1 second gives 1 coulomb. A small pen torch (AA) battery has about 1500mAh, so about 5400 coulombs in it (1.5A x 3600 seconds).

    Let's imagine one sphere is attached to a massive piston weighing 1 ton (1000 kg). Other sphere is held fixed 1 meter away. Now you give 1 mili coulombs negative and positive to both spheres each. The piston gets a force of 9000 newtons, and from F= MA, is accelerated 9 ms-2, hits other charge and gets canceled. Then you charge them back with both positive at 1 mili coulombs, so the piston goes back.

    Remember. 1 pen torch battery has 5400 coulombs, so 5.4 million mili coulombs. Since 1 time takes 2x2=4 mili coulombs, one battery can do this 1.35 million times. Since a day has 86400 seconds, if it's done once per second, it can do this for more than 16 days or more than two weeks.

    You read that right! From this setup, a single pen torch battery can move a 1 ton (1000 kg) piston back and forth 1 meter (as in piston stroke), 1 time per second for two weeks. Just imagine how massive 1 ton piston is, and if it can move 1 meter back and forth every second for 2 weeks, how much energy that is! Easily like a big power plant like නොරොච්චෝලේ.

    This is obviously ridiculous, but Math checks out! Either coulomb's law is fake, or we can power sri lanka with a few pen torch batteries. If you can, prove me wrong.
     
    Last edited:

    tharakaf

    Well-known member
  • Oct 19, 2020
    36,163
    74,419
    113
    Do you remember coulomb's law? We learned it in middle school. It gives the force between two charges.

    View attachment 175066

    So if we place two spheres charged with 1 coulomb negative and positive each, 1 meter apart, the attraction force between them is about 9 Billion Newtons! (9,000,000,000 N!) That is enough force to lift 900,000 tons.

    1 coulomb is not huge. By define of amps, a current flow of 1 ampere for 1 second gives 1 coulomb. A small pen torch (AA) battery has about 1500mAh, so about 5400 coulombs in it (1.5A x 3600 seconds).

    Let's imagine one sphere is attached to a massive piston weighing 1000 tons. Other sphere is held 1 meter away. Now you give 1 mili coulombs negative and positive to both spheres each. The piston gets a force of 9 million newtons, and from F= MA, is accelerated 9 ms-2, hits other charge and gets canceled. Then you charge them back with both positive at 1 mili coulombs, so the piston goes back.

    Remember. 1 pen torch battery has 5400 coulombs, so 5.4 million mili coulombs. Since 1 time takes 2x2=4 mili coulombs, one battery can do this 1.35 million times. Since a day has 86400 seconds, if it's done once per second, it can do this for more than 16 days or more than two weeks.

    You read that right! From this setup, a single pen torch battery can move a 1000 ton piston back and forth 1 meter (as in piston stroke), 1 time per second for two weeks. Just imagine how massive 1000 ton piston is, and if it can move 1 meter for 2 weeks, how much energy that is! Easily more than 10 නොරොච්චෝලේ power plants.

    This is obviously ridiculous, but Math checks out! Either coulomb's law is fake, or we can power sri lanka with a few pen torch batteries. If you can, prove me wrong.
    Well mofo this is the same reason why JVP fuckers are good at talking and shit at working.

    Why --> Theories sometimes don't make sense in the practical world because of assumptions and idea situations and shit :ROFLMAO: :ROFLMAO:
     

    Ridunapm

    Well-known member
  • Jun 22, 2022
    2,005
    2,673
    113
    Well mofo this is the same reason why JVP fuckers are good at talking and shit at working.

    Why --> Theories sometimes don't make sense in the practical world because of assumptions and idea situations and shit :ROFLMAO: :ROFLMAO:

    Like what? Are you saying you can't charge a metal sphere? Which part is wrong with practical world? Can you elaborate please?
     

    olu bakka

    Well-known member
  • Aug 18, 2011
    22,705
    23,368
    113
    A small pen torch (AA) battery has about 1500mAh, so about 5400 coulombs in it (1.5A x 3600 seconds).
    The battery got 5400 coulomb negative charges and also positive charges. Having some charges doesn't mean it has energy. It's about how separate they're. That's called the potential. Potential or Voltage is the driving force of the electrons and that's where electricity or energy come from.

    And also if a 1.5V battery gives 1.5A current for 3600 seconds then the energy stored in that battery could be found simply by
    E =VIt
    E = 1.5*1.5*3600 = 8100 J
     

    tharakaf

    Well-known member
  • Oct 19, 2020
    36,163
    74,419
    113
    Like what? Are you saying you can't charge a metal sphere? Which part is wrong with practical world? Can you elaborate please?
    Well sonny, I didn't even bother to read it because some idiot on EK is trying to disprove an old theory.

    Who should I put my money on, the guy who created this theory or some idiot on EK who is trying to disapprove it :-D ? I will let you guess
     

    Ridunapm

    Well-known member
  • Jun 22, 2022
    2,005
    2,673
    113
    The battery got 5400 coulomb negative charges and also positive charges. Having some charges doesn't mean it has energy. It's about how separate they're. That's called the potential. Potential or Voltage is the driving force of electrons and that's where electricity come from.
    Exactly, instead of having 5400 coulombs seperate in the battery, we take 1 mili coulomb from it each and seperate it between two spheres. 👍

    Well sonny, I didn't even bother to read it because some idiot on EK is trying to disprove an old theory.

    Who should I put my money on, the guy who created this theory or some idiot on EK who is trying to disapprove it :-D ? I will let you guess
    I don't ask money. Just show me what's wrong here. Are you just believing what people say?
    ------ Post added on Jun 22, 2022 at 9:45 AM
     

    olu bakka

    Well-known member
  • Aug 18, 2011
    22,705
    23,368
    113
    Exactly, instead of having 5400 coulombs seperate in the battery, we take 1 mili coulomb from it each and seperate it between two spheres. 👍
    Can you suggest a way to get 1 mC to a sphere?

    (I know you posted this thread for sarcasm. But I'm commenting anyway. Someone will learn something)
     

    AEG

    Well-known member
  • Jul 5, 2012
    3,517
    6,372
    113
    Do you remember coulomb's law? We learned it in middle school. It gives the force between two charges.

    View attachment 175066

    So if we place two spheres charged with 1 coulomb negative and positive each, 1 meter apart, the attraction force between them is about 9 Billion Newtons! (9,000,000,000 N!) That is enough force to lift 900,000 tons.

    1 coulomb is not huge. By define of amps, a current flow of 1 ampere for 1 second gives 1 coulomb. A small pen torch (AA) battery has about 1500mAh, so about 5400 coulombs in it (1.5A x 3600 seconds).

    Let's imagine one sphere is attached to a massive piston weighing 1 ton (1000 kg). Other sphere is held fixed 1 meter away. Now you give 1 mili coulombs negative and positive to both spheres each. The piston gets a force of 9000 newtons, and from F= MA, is accelerated 9 ms-2, hits other charge and gets canceled. Then you charge them back with both positive at 1 mili coulombs, so the piston goes back.

    Remember. 1 pen torch battery has 5400 coulombs, so 5.4 million mili coulombs. Since 1 time takes 2x2=4 mili coulombs, one battery can do this 1.35 million times. Since a day has 86400 seconds, if it's done once per second, it can do this for more than 16 days or more than two weeks.

    You read that right! From this setup, a single pen torch battery can move a 1 ton (1000 kg) piston back and forth 1 meter (as in piston stroke), 1 time per second for two weeks. Just imagine how massive 1 ton piston is, and if it can move 1 meter back and forth every second for 2 weeks, how much energy that is! Easily like a big power plant like නොරොච්චෝලේ.

    This is obviously ridiculous, but Math checks out! Either coulomb's law is fake, or we can power sri lanka with a few pen torch batteries. If you can, prove me wrong.
    problem is charges get discharged as soon an they are given to the spheres. Either by discharging to atmosphere or to each other. how do you electrically separate them ?
     
    • Like
    Reactions: 07sanjeewakaru

    07sanjeewakaru

    Well-known member
  • Feb 9, 2013
    5,529
    1,811
    113
    ලංකාවෙ අඩා...!
    Uba science da kare...ela..ela....

    Sphere charge karanna ehema ba yako....Ekata oya output wena energyta wada energyak waya wenawa....2nd Law of Thermo dynamics...

    Remember. 1 pen torch battery has 5400 coulombs, so 5.4 million mili coulombs. Since 1 time takes 2x2=4 mili coulombs, one battery can do this 1.35 million times. Since a day has 86400 seconds, if it's done once per second, it can do this for more than 16 days or more than two weeks.

    Yako ubata oona time walata sphere charge wenne na...Spehere eke time constant walata charge wela iwara wenne...Ubata oona widihata control karanna controller danna oone...ethakota badu hari....:rofl:
     
    Last edited:

    tharakaf

    Well-known member
  • Oct 19, 2020
    36,163
    74,419
    113
    Uba scince da kare...ela..ela....

    Sphere charge karanna ehema ba yako....Ekata oya output wena energyta wada energyak waya wenawa....2nd Law of Thermo dynamics...

    Remember. 1 pen torch battery has 5400 coulombs, so 5.4 million mili coulombs. Since 1 time takes 2x2=4 mili coulombs, one battery can do this 1.35 million times. Since a day has 86400 seconds, if it's done once per second, it can do this for more than 16 days or more than two weeks.

    Yako ubata oona time walata sphere charge wenne na...Spehere eke time constant walata charge wela iwara wenne...Ubata oona widihata control karanna controller danna oone...ethakota badu hari....:rofl:
    Well mofo this is the same reason why JVP fuckers are good at talking and shit at working.

    Why --> Theories sometimes don't make sense in the practical world because of assumptions and idea situations and shit :ROFLMAO: :ROFLMAO:

    @Ridunapm See :-D, The gentleman @07sanjeewakaru just proved my point
     
    • Haha
    Reactions: 07sanjeewakaru