වැඩේ වැරදුනා

[Suryaa]

තාප්පෙට නම් මොකද!

කෙලියා කුරානෙට..හිහ් හිහ් හී!

So how are you going to prove that Holy Quran is corrupted. Modayo there were numbers of copies produced when the Quran was bind as a book. even today there are two originals, one in Istanbul Museum, Turkey and other is in one of the museums in Russia. why do you about the one destroyed in Yemen. You can easily check with the original available in those two countries

 

[Proxies]

තාප්පෙට නම් මොකද!

කෙලියා කුරානෙට..හිහ් හිහ් හී!

So how are you going to prove that Holy Quran is corrupted. Modayo there were numbers of copies produced when the Quran was bind as a book. even today there are two originals, one in Istanbul Museum, Turkey and other is in one of the museums in Russia. why do you about the one destroyed in Yemen. You can easily check with the original available in those two countries

Wena weda neththam hondai thope poth hoya hoya inna...

 

[Suryaa]

Wena weda neththam hondai thope poth hoya hoya inna...

learn to read English first

 

[ජිංතක ජිල්ලබකිට]

Let's see how pure Buddhist scriptures are. "

Historical criticism has proved that the original teachings of Buddha can never be known. It seems that Gautama Buddha’s teachings were memorized by his disciples. After Buddha’s death a council was held at Rajagaha so that the words of Buddha could be recited and agreed upon. There were differences of opinion and conflicting memories in the council. Opinion of Kayshapa and Ananda who were prominent disciples of Buddha were given preference. A hundred years later, a second council at Vesali was held. Only after 400 years, after the death of Buddha were his teachings and doctrines written down. Little attention was paid regarding its authenticity, genuineness and purity.

Who ever this Ahmed, I must thank him for the great job he is doing.

What ever it is it is very clear that there were 3 Buddhist councils to clear out any misunderstanding and wrong interpretations. What is most important is that it was done in a very democratic way.

But what about Quran? As Ahmed points out the Sana Quran is the oldest and most authentic, yet there is physical evidence to prove that it is indeed changed! On top of that the quran contain ABROGATED VERSES, as claimed by many and Ahmed makes a valid point on authenticity of the GOD's involvement in Quran.

None of these questions raised are not even addressed properly by anyone in this forum, but many rush to point the finger at Buddhist scriptures!

I suggest someone with courage, to reply with facts and reason.

 

[Suryaa]

[/SIZE]

Who ever this Ahmed, I must thank him for the great job he is doing.

What ever it is it is very clear that there were 3 Buddhist councils to clear out any misunderstanding and wrong interpretations. What is most important is that it was done in a very democratic way.

But what about Quran? As Ahmed points out the Sana Quran is the oldest and most authentic, yet there is physical evidence to prove that it is indeed changed! On top of that the quran contain ABROGATED VERSES, as claimed by many and Ahmed makes a valid point on authenticity of the GOD's involvement in Quran.

None of these questions raised are not even addressed properly by anyone in this forum, but many rush to point the finger at Buddhist scriptures!

I suggest someone with courage, to reply with facts and reason.

.
Today only I saw a person has raised question in a proper manner. Quran is pre-saved last 1400 plus years 100%. The clarification what I have given already is more than enough. Example one Mr. X printing a book with 100 copies. after a few years you bring one copy, out of hundred and say look some body has written some thing over it, so the book originality has been lost" . Our question what about the other 99 copies.

In addition to that, According Islamic belief an angel called "Gerbil" brought the Quran to earth over 23 yeas and it was memorised by heart by Prophet Muhammed (PBUH). From that time it has been passed generation to generation by heart (memorizing)even today each and every village in the earth, there will be at least 02 or 03 people who has memorized the Quran by heart. They are called "Hafiz". Ask some in your village for Hafiz. In this earth there is no any other religion script memorised by like this.

Meanwhile, a companion of Prophet Muhammed (PBUH) and the third Calif
(Ruler) Usman wanted bring the Quran in printed format. Thus he made number of copies (not known the number). Even today two copies can found in Istanbul and Russian museums.

Please note that we have courage to give any clarification about Islam with scientifically wherever necessary. you may come up with any cross question again. But let us know in which point you disagree. Hope you will not disappear from this point.

In the meantime I have raised number of question about Buddhism. No one has replied till to date. They were ignored as if they didn't see those. Actually we knew most of the Buddhists don't even know about their own scripture. Finally there is no proper answers for them.

 

[Proxies]

learn to read English first

තෝ එඅක කියල තියෙන්නෙත් එන්ග්ලිෂ් වලින් නේ බල්ලෝ ......ඉගෙන ගනින් සිංහල කියවන්න......

 

[ex-muslim Ahmed]

.
Today only I saw a person has raised question in a proper manner. Quran is pre-saved last 1400 plus years 100%. The clarification what I have given already is more than enough.

Really? May be for you it is enough but for a neutral person with basic logical analysis capabilities, this is not a meaningful coherent reply. You have not replied to specific points raised by me in several occasions in this forum.

1) SANA's Quran is in fact, is tampered and its content is changed. This is clearly evident in physical evidence produced. whats your specific reply to nullify this claim??

2) you have not answered to the point that there are ABROGATED VERSES in the Quran. This is a fact and, if it so, is the Quran is the work of God?, since God is Omnipotent and does not make MISTAKES! What is your Specific reply to nullify this criticism??

. Example one Mr. X printing a book with 100 copies. after a few years you bring one copy, out of hundred and say look some body has written some thing over it, so the book originality has been lost" . Our question what about the other 99 copies.

This is a shallow argument. The basic flaw in this logic is that there were no PRINTING machines at that time. One copy gave rise to the next and that copy to another..and so on. If the oldest or one of the oldest was changed that meant all the other 99 copies arising from that were also flawed, corrupt and wrong!

.
In addition to that, According Islamic belief an angel called "Gerbil" brought the Quran to earth over 23 yeas and it was memorised by heart by Prophet Muhammed (PBUH). From that time it has been passed generation to generation by heart (memorizing)even today each and every village in the earth, there will be at least 02 or 03 people who has memorized the Quran by heart. They are called "Hafiz". Ask some in your village for Hafiz. In this earth there is no any other religion script memorised by like this.

This is again just repeating the history. you are unable bring forward any argument, logic or fact. Just repeating the same old history does not make your claim right. I am No Buddhist but i think Buddhist scriptures, which is much more complex and philosophical was memorized until it was written. On top of that they also had some kind of council of priests to preserve the purity of scriptures. So your claim that " no other religious script is memorized" is just a lie.

.
Please note that we have courage to give any clarification about Islam with scientifically wherever necessary. you may come up with any cross question again. But let us know in which point you disagree. Hope you will not disappear from this point.

Having courage without the basic reasoning skills and facts could be lethal. one word for that is "Stupidity". None of the issued raised has been clarified so far. see above.

Don't use the largest font size to make your point. It does not make you right, but shows that you are trying to compensate for your weak reason and logic by "cyber Shouting".

.
In the meantime I have raised number of question about Buddhism. No one has replied till to date. They were ignored as if they didn't see those. Actually we knew most of the Buddhists don't even know about their own scripture. Finally there is no proper answers for them.

This out of my scope and interest. I Hope some Buddhist will answer you if you raise proper meaningful questions.

 

[Suryaa]

තෝ එඅක කියල තියෙන්නෙත් එන්ග්ලිෂ් වලින් නේ බල්ලෝ ......ඉගෙන ගනින් සිංහල කියවන්න......

සිංහල දැන් ලංකාවටත් අවශ්‍ය නැහැ

 

[Red Ro$$]

සිංහල දැන් ලංකාවටත් අවශ්‍ය නැහැ

 

[Suryaa]

Really? May be for you it is enough but for a neutral person with basic logical analysis capabilities, this is not a meaningful coherent reply. You have not replied to specific points raised by me in several occasions in this forum.

1) SANA's Quran is in fact, is tampered and its content is changed. This is clearly evident in physical evidence produced. whats your specific reply to nullify this claim??

2) you have not answered to the point that there are ABROGATED VERSES in the Quran. This is a fact and, if it so, is the Quran is the work of God?, since God is Omnipotent and does not make MISTAKES! What is your Specific reply to nullify this criticism??



This is a shallow argument. The basic flaw in this logic is that there were no PRINTING machines at that time. One copy gave rise to the next and that copy to another..and so on. If the oldest or one of the oldest was changed that meant all the other 99 copies arising from that were also flawed, corrupt and wrong!



This is again just repeating the history. you are unable bring forward any argument, logic or fact. Just repeating the same old history does not make your claim right. I am No Buddhist but i think Buddhist scriptures, which is much more complex and philosophical was memorized until it was written. On top of that they also had some kind of council of priests to preserve the purity of scriptures. So your claim that " no other religious script is memorized" is just a lie.


Having courage without the basic reasoning skills and facts could be lethal. one word for that is "Stupidity". None of the issued raised has been clarified so far. see above.

Don't use the largest font size to make your point. It does not make you right, but shows that you are trying to compensate for your weak reason and logic by "cyber Shouting".



This out of my scope and interest. I Hope some Buddhist will answer you if you raise proper meaningful questions.

I think you forgot to use you fake account when you reply to this post. see below self praising.This is called getting caught red handed. your arguments also fake like this. However we will reply to this as this is not argument at all to us.


Originally Posted by ජිංතක ජිල්ලබකිට


Who ever this Ahmed, I must thank him for the great job he is doing..... .
[/SIZE]

 

[ex-muslim Ahmed]

I think you forgot to use you fake account when you reply to this post. see below self praising.This is called getting caught red handed. your arguments also fake like this. However we will reply to this as this is not argument at all to us.


Originally Posted by ජිංතක ජිල්ලබකිට


Who ever this Ahmed, I must thank him for the great job he is doing..... .
[/SIZE]

This shallow argument speaks for your level of intelligence.

I responded to the post as I have posted on numerous occasions about Islam and its unscientific, irrational and uncultured ways of thinking. I am a ex-muslim and in that context I am a suitable person to comment on propaganda posts on Islam.

Please check my post list if you have doubts. Any body can respond to any post as this is a PUBLIC forum.

You have a lot learn about basic etiquette and general knowledge before responding to my questions!

 

[amjad18]

මෙයින් පෙන්වන්නේ බංකොලොත් බාවයයි
​