Is this true?buddha said such a thing?

[Emios]

 

[Emios]

 

[snm1990]

නිවන ගැන නේද මේ කියන්නේ? එක වෙනස් නොවෙන එකක් කියල.

 

[Emios]

නිවන ගැන නේද මේ කියන්නේ? එක වෙනස් නොවෙන එකක් කියල.

 

[dinukap4]

25min labbak balanna ba bung mokakda kiyala tiyenne simple explanation ekak dipanko

 

[Emios]

25min labbak balanna ba bung mokakda kiyala tiyenne simple explanation ekak dipanko

There is an eternel substance in universe.Buddha is talking about it.If nothing is eternel how something can be eternel.He explains it

 

[dinukap4]

There is an eternel substance in universe.Buddha is talking about it.If nothing is eternel how something can be eternel.He explains it

All my life what I've been thought and heard is nothing is eternal

 

[Emios]

All my life what I've been thought and heard is nothing is eternal

That's what i'm asking

 

[Pessimist]

There is an eternel substance in universe.Buddha is talking about it.If nothing is eternel how something can be eternel.He explains it

i think what he's doing is try to give an ontological description to nirvana. that's the easiest way to understand just about anything. but i dont think it's right to consider it(nirvana) as a substance sunyathavada is about denying the very idea of substance as per my understanding.
if u want to learn more on this read the articles below
https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/substance/
https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/nagarjuna/

 

[Emios]

i think what he's doing is try to give an ontological description to nirvana. that's the easiest way to understand just about anything. but i dont think it's right to consider it(nirvana) as a substance sunyathavada is about denying the very idea of substance as per my understanding.
if u want to learn more on this read the articles below
https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/substance/
https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/nagarjuna/

Now i'm confused.I can't see a difference between nirvana and pure coniousness in hindunism because they have a eternal substance too called pure consiousness.

 

[Pessimist]

Now i'm confused.I can't see a difference between nirvana and pure coniousness in hindunism because they have a eternal substance too called pure consiousness.

well they both arose in ancient india. so it's quite normal for one school to borrow ideas from another school.

 

[Emios]

well they both arose in ancient india. so it's quite normal for one school to borrow ideas from another school.

So it's the same.Only the path to go there is different

 

[Pessimist]

So it's the same.Only the path to go there is different

not exactly. verbal descriptions can only take u so far. they are there as a guide. read some more articles on the topic sunyathavada. ud understand what i mean. people have to use concepts found among general population to explain their insights even when they go beyond simple concepts we use in our day to day life. so when somebody came up with some profound concept like sunyathavada it's normal for everybody to try and give some sunthayavadi explanation to their ideas. just because some 2 explanations sounds similar doesnt mean they both refer to the same thing

 

[Emios]

not exactly. verbal descriptions can only take u so far. they are there as a guide. read some more articles on the topic sunyathavada. ud understand what i mean. people have to use concepts found among general population to explain their insights even when they go beyond simple concepts we use in our day to day life. so when somebody came up with some profound concept like sunyathavada it's normal for everybody to try and give some sunthayavadi explanation to their ideas. just because some 2 explanations sounds similar doesnt mean they both refer to the same thing

Ok but it really sounds simmilar unbound unborn no frame etc

 

[slickdeath]

You know what other thing lord Buddha said, never believe people trying to gain views on youtube by using him.

 

[sanoka]

In Hindu tradition, nirvana (more commonly called moksha) is the reuniting with Brahman,the biggest differences between Hinduism and Buddhism.

 

[Emios]

In Hindu tradition, nirvana (more commonly called moksha) is the reuniting with Brahman,the biggest differences between Hinduism and Buddhism.

What is the difference.It sounds same

 

[mr90486]

That's what i'm asking

In this world, at this moment there are no one who can answer your question. There can be but even if they are, we may not be intellectual enough to understand what they explain. Nowadays, the most foolish thing people do is trying to understand something without making an effort to get there in the first place. As a simple example, its like a 6 year old is trying to pass A/L examination. Its impossible for the 6 year old until he reaches that level step by step by following the same path shown by the person who achieved it first. Hope you get the point.

 

[sanoka]

In this world, at this moment there are no one who can answer your question. There can be but even if they are, we may not be intellectual enough to understand what they explain. Nowadays, the most foolish thing people do is trying to understand something without making an effort to get there in the first place. As a simple example, its like a 6 year old is trying to pass A/L examination. Its impossible for the 6 year old until he reaches that level step by step by following the same path shown by the person who achieved it first. Hope you get the point.

Exactly... 'Ehi passiko'
Nirwana cannot be explain by words.

Rebirth caused by attachments.
Suffering caused by Rebirth.

End the attachments (Does not mean , not married no kids policy ).

Same Perfume may give different thoughts to two different people, Yet that perfume is the same, which made difference is your Keles (Wrongful ideas).


When you blow out a candle, what happened to that little flame, where did it go ? can you explain it to a little kid Nope, It does not exists as the reasons are no more.

No reason no result.
No attachment no existance

This is the very basics... go deep you'll find more...
Reading and understanding is not going with Buddhism.

 

[Emios]

Looks like everybody commenting without watching the video.