daddyimmo said:
Look not only Islam civilization has contributes to modern science also other civilizations
Allah has only revealed the Quraan and in the Quraan there are verses which was support for the Muslims which they did experiments on it! As an example in the Surah Ar-Ra’d stated:
“And it is He who spread out the earth, and set thereon mountains standing firm and (flowing) rivers: and fruit of every kind He made in pairs, two and two: He draweth the night as a veil o'er the Day. Behold, verily in these things there are signs for those who consider! And in the earth are tracts (diverse though) neighboring, and gardens of vines and fields sown with corn, and palm trees - growing out of single roots or otherwise: watered with the same water, yet some of them We make more excellent than others to eat. Behold, verily in these things there are signs for those who understand!” (13:3-4)
So base on this Surah, Al-Khwārizmī has work on his book of the appearance of the Earth" or "The image of the Earth" in 833 which was considered as geography! And you know Columbus wondered by evaluating this book and said that if this book says that the earth is a shape of a spherical, then traveling from the west to the east there should be a path or a road to reach each side! And so that is how he traveled and found America in 1942. Even more Muslims were involved in this subject!
Al-Khwārizmī has not only contribute to geography but to many
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muhammad_ibn_M%C5%ABs%C4%81_al-Khw%C4%81rizm%C4%AB
Even more Muslims in history have contributed by their own effort!
http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special%3ASearch&search=The+Golden+Islam&ns0=1
Well, even before Q'ran appeared people lived in this world and thrived didn't they? They did not refer to any divine text.. so what about them? So assuming that Allah is the creator of human.. why did not he create the first human and give the Q'ran to his hand and said "everything thing you need to know is here!". if you tell me this way.. then at least it makes sense!
Al-Khwarizmi was born in 780AD and his main contributions in Mathematics, (from the source you've given me) but bro... even '0' was invented in 5th century BC, way before Q'ran has been found/revealed! So how can you give credit to Q'ran in accordance with Al-Khwarizmi services?
daddyimmo said:
What help? Look Allah has already given the guidance by the revelation of his message which is the Quraan! Only thing you don’t accept! That’s normal to you!
Well.. if all appears normal to me then we would not be having this discussion in the first place

daddyimmo said:
There is nothing to think about! You are thinking that I’m a narrow-minded! What about this fellow, what about that fellow are the questions you are asking! For what?
Dont jump into conclusions now!!

daddyimmo said:
Look whether it is Albert or whoever we are all human beings and Allah has given humankind the will and the ability to think! And among us there can be different viewers! So there will be people who will disprove the Quraan and there will be people who will believe in it! There can be great scientists who are Muslims and non Muslims! There are twins born conjoint! There are children who are born abnormal and normal!
So Allah has created the human being not in way who are born Muslims are the best and not in a way who is born non Muslims are the worse! Once again Allah has given the humankind the will! So there will be different people having different choice!
If Allah has made Albert Einstein as a non-Muslim and a great scientist, it does not mean that he will not be taken to judgment also whether a person is a Muslim! As Allah has given the will to humankind and so Albert Einstein, he will be judge for his deeds in earth for the hereafter which he will be deserve heaven or fire. May peace be upon Albert Einstein!
Look for those were born abnormal Allah is most forgiver! But who have the knowledge and still disprove Allah deserve them punishment
This earth is a test for the hereafter!
Allah forgives who only follow the guidance of Allah and deserve punishment to those who rejects and disbelieve!
Ok that's exactly what I'm asking here... see Einstien did perhaps the greatest service to mankind in the modern world.. so he did good deeds even though he wasn't a Muslim, so if Allah... like you say would consider his good deeds but then what would be his (Allah's) decision?
Will he..
Decides "Ok.. this person did a lot of good, even though he is not a Muslim I'm sending him to heaven"
or
"Ok.. this guy did lot of good deed but since he isn't a Muslim I'm sending him to Hell"
in which case both seems odd to me.. because in 1st case then you don't necessarily have to be a Muslim to go to where Muslims go after death! in the second case, just because you are not a Muslim whatever good you do doesn't matter, you will still go to Hell!!
So clear out for me.. which one? please!!
daddyimmo said:
You think that a person who has belief in god will always ask for divine help? Which concept is that?
WHY NOT?

You believe he is out there somewhere right? So you mean you don't believe he can do this or what? If you dont believe a simple thing like this then how do you believe he created a Universe? or you just not ask help for these kind of small things
But for a GOD who created a Universe this can be fixed in a jiffy right?
I dunno.. your choice!! I'm just asking....
daddyimmo said:
I know the way you are thinking! If I asked divine help you think it will be cured? Silly! I would take care myself! Look in this earth Allah has given us the physical and non physical feelings! So if we fall somewhere we will be hurt! Likewise if we use our mind to the wrong path we will be doing wrong things! That is something normal brother! So we need only to be careful, though it is not easy!
No matter how careful you are if someone else is not careful he can harm you that's also called an accident.. (most of the time)
So always being perfect is impossible, unless a GOD of Allah's caliber makes human perfect.. (now I wonder why he didn't)
daddyimmo said:
You believe that there is god only if you see him! But if God send a messenger to the people and if god sends a message to the people, you won’t believe!
Now it is clear for me how you see at Islam! And it is clear for me why you don’t believe! I’m not trying to convince you and won’t convince you! It’s not my duty As Allah said in the Quraan:
“Let there be no compulsion in religion: Truth stands out clear from Error: whoever rejects evil and believes in Allah has grasped the most trustworthy hand-hold that never breaks. And Allah hears and knows all things.”
NO! I'm not saying you MUST see to believe! But it SURE does helps.. Are you denying that? that's human nature... or should I say.. the very nature that Allah created in human beings... so he should understand it better than us!
daddyimmo said:
We believe Jesus (Isa) PBUH as one of the prophets of Allah before Muhammad (PBUH) and he also gave the same message of Allah like Muhammad (PBUH) as it is there in the Quraan stated:
“We have sent thee inspiration, as We sent it to Noah and the Messengers after him: we sent inspiration to Abraham, Isma'il, Isaac, Jacob and the Tribes, to Jesus, Jacob, Jonah, Aaron, and Solomon, and to David We gave the Psalms.” (4:163)
Allah revealed to Jesus (Isa) PBUH the (inspiration) message which is called the Injiil (Gospel). Allah revealed to Moses (Musa) PBUH the (inspiration) message which is called the Tawraat (Torah). Allah revealed to David (Dawud) PBUH the (inspiration) message which is called the Psalms (Zabur) and which the statement in the Quraan Allah revealed it to Muhammad (PBUH)
So does this means, all Christians will not be punished on the Judgment day?
Because they followed a Prophet of Allah! If so... then again.. you don't have to be a Muslim to go to heaven?
daddyimmo said:
A disciple means the one who follow! Allah does want all his mankind to follow his guidance! So if you are telling why he doesn’t appear, as I have mentioned it before, if the people don’t believe in the existence of Allah’s signs, Allah’s Angels, Allah’s Messengers, Allah’s books, The day of resurrection and hereafter! How would the people believe then there is one true god i.e. Allah when he appears? After appearing will the people then remove their previous belief, regret and follow Allah’s guidance! Then I have to ask how you will or in which reason you will remove the belief in Buddhism you have?
Allah will not appear! And I know according to Buddhism you will completely ignore it!
Actually say if someone says you don't exist, what better way to convince that person other than you show him you sure does exist? If you send messengers and angels etc. etc. the more the people will dis believe you!! This is just common sense.. if you want people to believe you, stop beating around the bush... just present what they don't believe.. end of the story.. why go through all this criticism?
daddyimmo said:
Then I have to ask how you will or in which reason you will remove the belief in Buddhism you have?
Maybe the day Allah stop sending someone behalf of him and appears himself and prove all this is his creation!!
daddyimmo said:
And if you are telling that if god appears people will follow him! Then why still some convert to Islam and did they ever want to see god just like you ask?
That is people's choice.. every person is different.. this question you should Allah.. not me!!
daddyimmo said:
Allah has revealed the message as stated in the Quraan
“Those who do not know say: .Why is it that Allah does not speak to us, nor does a sign come to us? So spoke those before them as these people do. Their hearts resemble each other. We have indeed made the signs clear for the people who have certitude.Surely, We have sent you with the truth, as a bearer of good tidings, and a warner, and you will not be asked about the people of Hell.” (2:118)
But I don know why you’ll won’t believe what Muhammad (PBUH) has told, the revelation of the Quraan which is the message of Allah! I have to ask you that! Please reply me that!
Because, if there's only ONE TRUE GOD, then I can't see any reason why.. for him not to present himself to the people (like you guys) whom pray for him day and night.. Here I'm talking as a Human to GOD not as a Buddhist...
If human have this much of faith on you... what possible reason you have not to appear yourself and let them hear your words and wisdom from you!!??
daddyimmo said:
We believe that there is god not just for the sake! We believe as Allah has revealed the message and all the prophets of Islam has spread the message of Allah and proved it! But some ignored it and still some disprove! How much you see and how much you hear you won’t believe as in the Quraan Allah asks and says:
“And who believe in what has been revealed to you and what has been revealed before you; and they have faith in the Hereafter.” (2:4)
“Surely for those who have disbelieved, it is all the same whether you warn them or you warn them not: they do not believe. Allah has set a seal on their hearts and on their hearing; and on their eyes there is a covering, and for them awaits a mighty punishment.” (2:6-7}
It will not make any difference to such people whether you warn them or not, they will not believe. Allah has set a seal on their hearts and on their hearing and on their eyes is a veil. It is not because Allah has set a seal on their hearts that these non-Muslims do not understand and believe, but it is the vice-versa. It is because these non-Muslims are bent on rejecting the truth and whether you warn them or not they will not believe.
don’t expect Islam to be a philosophy!
According to Islam we believe that there is no any other god or greater than god and only one true god i.e. Allah, The Almighty, The All-Wise.
You say the Quraan does not give the freedom to choose! Why? The Quraan is the message of Allah and it is the guidance to those who fear for Allah! As in the Quraan states:
“This Book has no doubt in it - guidance for the God-fearing” (V 2:2)
So it doesn’t mean that we can’t have the choice to convert! It is Muslims fear for Allah for not going astray. So it is wrong to say that there is no freedom of choice! Allah has given humankind the will, so we have the choices! So a Muslim who converts from Islam to another means only he rejects Allah and his messengers! This means he has gone astray of Allah and he is taken into account of punishment in the hereafter! And it is not for only the Muslims! It also for those who rejects the beliefs of Allah for all humankind!
“Those who disbelieve after having accepted Faith and then increase in disbelief, their repentance shall never be accepted. They are the ones who have lost the right path.” (V 2:27)
“As for those who reject Faith and give the lie to Our Signs, they shall be companions of the Fire; they shall abide therein.” (V 2:39)
Ok! so let me get this straight & simple...
Allah creates human.. reveals Q'ran... and says "Ok I have given you the freedom to think as human"..
Then human uses that freedom to follow or explore other avenues... and the moment he does that.... he enters Allah's punishment LOG or something? So what's the freedom really means in Allah's book?
Does Allah means.. whatever you do you cannot be a non-Muslim? then what freedom is that?

