Dude when in hell have I told that DS2 is better than DS1? In every place I've spoken praised the ORIGINAL DARK SOULS. DARK SOULS 1.
And Dark Souls 2 didn't live up to that expectations. I stopped playing DS2 until the expansions come just because it was a fail after Dark Souls.
The wikipedia quotations, the review sites.. everything is about Dark Souls 1 neh

and you say that the whole argument is about Dark Souls 2. I've said in my previous comments that the vanilla DS2 is not that good. But the expansions were really good. all three expansions combined is way better than the vanilla content.
But still Dark Souls 1 is my favourite game on par with Witcher 2 and is one of the remarkable games of this generation.
You started this argument saying Bloodborne ain't good Dark Souls ain't good... But I guess you didn't know how to enjoy the game...
Why do I say it's pure RPG element? Because from the beginning you choose what you want to be. You choose the character.. You choose what skills you are gonna improve. You choose the weapons you want to fight with. You choose how you want to upgrade your weapons. You choose what type of tactics you're going to use to defeat a certain type of enemy or boss. You choose whether you want help or not to complete some place or defeat a boss... And you choose where you want to go first...You choose how to finish an NPC quest. And even at the end of the game.. you are given a choice. To keep the flame lit or start the age of Darkness.(Speaking of Dark Souls technically). And everything (I mean every damn thing from a weapon attack to a hard choice).. you learn by playing the game. A lot of stuff is hidden. (Even the controls) You have to explore everything and learn everything.By experience you tend to be better at the game. That's something only a handful of RPG's give to you.
There are some stress tests done by you tubers for Dark Souls 3. Go and see if you could. See what the hype is about. Watch a single player mode and the boss fight with "The Dancer"
Here's a link if you want
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b6yqv0J-BQE
And Miyazaki himself is developing the game. So it'll be better if not the best.
And for the case of Witcher 3 I absolutely love the game. I collected every single update and still haven't played the game because want to spend some long hours for that. The Witcher is also a rare piece of work based on the masterpiece by Andrzej Sapkowski