just said:
you should answer my questions then ask me, i dnt see any answer here just questions, you dont have to ask again and again buddy, i clearly have stated i believe in punishment for deserving in order to keep the society clean..CLEAR??
Oh! you were asking when person does commit a crime does he know its good or bad? Ofcourse he knows.... so what's the difference between you and the criminal? If dont have money I think of robbing a bank...

(seriously sometimes

) but if I attempt it.. aha... then I'm a criminal.. so there lies a gap between thinking about it and dare to try it... right? that daring act is the one that matters and should be contained and tamed self-contained...
Anyhow would'nt it be better if people understand the bad side of crime and staying away from it than scared of getting their limbs chopped off? You'd say its the same result... I'd come to that later!!!
just said:
but you should put your answer without beating around. k say a guy rapes and murders a young girl cold bloodedly..(practically happens in sl).you would say put him to rehab, and give your deepest sympathies for the girls family? thats wat i get from your answer. correct me if im wrong
Aha...there you go! you missed the point but you bought up a perfect example for me to explain the word "deserving" that you used earlier!!
According to your scenario... A guy rapes and murders... Now that's 2 crimes right there according to our legal system... rape & murder... and if you take rape there are many categories that the criminal belongs to such as..
Rape, Aggravated Rape, Statutory Rape, Incest etc. etc.
For each of these.. the punishment also varies... for example for Rape a criminal would get up to 20 Years Imprisonment + Fine + Compensation for Victim
for Aggravated Rape Minimum punishment would be 10 years plus all other "bonuses"
And according to your scenario the guy now faces 2 charges... rape and murder and 2 punishment...1 for rape / aggravated rape that will cost him 20 years + capital punishment or life imprisonment for murder + Fine + Compensation for Victim.....and murder is totally a different arena mind you!
So lets say yet another guy get caught raping someone else, but not killing her....then probably he will get 7 to 20 years in prison... now that's deserving.. because he is lesser criminal than the earlier guy who not only raped but killed!!
So rehab is just a part of it working alongside this system...its NOT THE ONLY THING!!!
just said:
"I really don't know!" hmmmm atleast you are frank..but one thing only hoping wouldnt do any good
Yup.. Lets hope Arabs will quit smoking too..
just said:
i see, so you saying again i give my sympathies to all women in sl, but im afraid we cant do anythin abt it cos the root cause is financial inbalance that we cant figure a solution to..

Aiyo!!! Dont type whatever comes to your mind.... I said mostly the root cause is
MONEY, and there are separate rules to punish such people.. dont you know? Next time smack a lady in the face and see for yourself..get 1st hand experience!!!


just said:
we are not talking about the system here. we are talking about the punishment to the "Deserving" as a slotion. any system cannot give 100%
just said:
beliefs get a value only if they can be implemented practically..but i respect your opinion
can i know your opinion about how such system works in a practical situation, ie implementing it in our country?or will you say ask president im here only ask questions..

Coming back to this question from the 1st section..... (Because I think its related)
I dont understand why would you think the system is not important.. because we are comparing two different streams of ruling... A Democracy and a Monarchy so each have different ways of ruling people!
Maybe you are trying so hard to tell that the at the end what is more practical that does matters.... but the way we do it is not important to you? that does reminds me of "helmet"..

You know what we used to call putting a "helmet" for O/L, sending someone else for the exam...you may send someone into the exam and get better results or you write yourself and get avg. results.. you may pass in any case but you gotta know what's more ethical!!
Last time I checked... there was never a country converted from Democracy to a Monarchy infact it was the other way around...the most recent example being Bhutan...and Democracy is accountable for all people's rights regardless of the nature of their behavior and that includes criminals too! So we can never have some sort of a Monarchy+Democracy Hybrid mix law

this doesn't happen...... So you either respect everyone's rights and stay democratic or ignore people's rights and start chopping limbs off and be a Monarchy fan boy.... it is up to you!
And lastly I quote from you..
just said:
....any system cannot give 100%