i have a question...

[wast123]

Listen! you are asking what you do not know! Am I correct? So how do you can argue its not correct? Then I assume you already know the answer.. if so why ask?

What you want us say? "Oh! Sorry Buddhism doesn't cover all this, I'm sorry" is that the answer you need? I think you are upto something else here!!

Well.... people cannot give answer of what makes YOU happy, IF ITS NOT THE ANSWER!!!

Lord Buddha doesn't take apart how to commit SIN as in many different industries!!

That's an impossible thing to do!! then you'd ask next "What happens if a Software Engineer kills someone or Doctor kills someone"

What I previously told you is not my answer... this is what Buddhism says!! ACCORDANCE WITH ITS PHILOSOPHY

There are 5 things taken into account if a human kills any living thing...... I MEAN ANY HUMAN KILLING ANY LIVING THING!

1. Victim should be alive
2. You should know its alive
3. You have a plan to kill
4. You execute the plan
5. You kill

complete the 5 thing you are officially guilty according to Buddhism!! BE IT A DOCTOR / LAWYER / DENTIST / PROGRAMMER / ENGINEER or EVEN SOLDIER!!

FOR ALL HUMANS!!! UNDERSTAND??? there's no SPECIAL RULES FOR ARMY PERSONAL ONLY!!! THEY FALL INTO HUMAN CATEGORY TOO!!

THAT'S THE PHILOSOPHY!!

Vry true!

 

[just]

Buddhism applies to all the humans... but they should be intelligent enough to grsp it.. otherwse no use of explaining anythng to them...

When it comes to soldiers ur problem comes bcz they kill people rte?
well... soldiers do not commit any serious sin.(like ananthariya papa karma) but they do commit sins... like anguli maala... but most probably their intentions r pure... they wnt to save many lives via sacrificng few..

But theres this issue in our religion(Buddhism) that the place and the manner of rebirth is decided mostly by the thoughts of a person at the time he was dying..
like Janaka karma...
Upa gathaka karma... and so on....

so if a soldier or even a monk has a bad thought at the time he was dying he surely be born in a bad place... or even can end up by becomng an animal...

But if a soldier as able to gain a good thought at the time of his death...
He surely will be born in a good place....

And im sure allmost all the soldiers who are fighting for us at this very moment have pure hopes of their motherland...
otherwise they also shud have been doing smethng else lke u and me...

So after they physically die... i thnk mst f them becmes Jathiyee mura devathavoo...

and continue their great effort!!!!!!!

thanks man.yeah maybe its not easy to get an diea easily i understand and frankly i have no much knowledge about what you talked here, if not i wouldnt have a question right? (still i get the general idea)

and you gave some clues which i can use to find out further, Thanks for your time

Listen! you are asking what you do not know! Am I correct? So how do you can argue its not correct? Then I assume you already know the answer.. if so why ask?

What you want us say? "Oh! Sorry Buddhism doesn't cover all this, I'm sorry" is that the answer you need? I think you are upto something else here!!

sorry man, i just asked a doubt here.and wanted to know more than what you told about it.if it made you think like that then its sad.anyways thanks for your time too.